Chapter
Three
A
Political Program.
The intifada is generally believed to have been a spontaneous
event unconnected to any leadership decision thus taking all political
and religious groupings by surprise. An accident on December 8th, 1987
which involved the death of several Palestinian workers in vehicles hit
by an Israeli truck began the riots that were the beginning of the intifada.
The following day leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood met to discuss how
the situation could be used to promote wider public demonstrations. This
group consisted of Sheikh Ahmad Yassin, founder of the Islamic Centre
and other key figures in the Centre including Dr. Abdul Aziz Ali Rantisi,
Dr. Ibrahim al-Yazuri, Sheikh Saleh Shehadeh, Issa al-Nashshar, Muhammed
Shama and Abed al-Fattah Dukhan. On December the 14th this group issued
a statement calling for resistance to the occupation which, retrospectively
was the first official leaflet of Hamas, although the group did not actually
go under that name until January 1988.
Between December
1987 and December 1988, Hamas issued around 33 leaflets.
[43]
(The number is not certain because they were not numbered
until May 1988 when number 21 appeared.) The leaflets drew heavily on
religious slogans and images unlike those distributed by the Unified Leadership
of the Uprising (Fateh\Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP),
Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine (DFLP) and Palestine
Communist Party (PCP) coalition) whose were longer, more detailed and
succinctly presented political arguments. All the leaflets set out to
dictate a routine for daily life but the Hamas leaflets addressed a broader
range of issues covering work, health, transportation, education and religious
instruction as well as declaring its own strike days.
Although the
leaflets illustrate that both groups have the same overriding goal which
is to establish a Palestinian state and remove Israel from the occupied
lands, Hamas goes much further, aiming to establish an Islamic state in
all of Palestine. Leaflet number 22 of June 1988 declares that "Our
war is a holy war for Allah unto victory or death." As far as Hamas is concerned, the Muslims right to all of Palestine
leaves no room for a political settlement with Israel: a Hamas leaflet
of March 1988 states, "Let every hand be cut off that signs a relinquishment
of a grain of the soil of Palestine to the enemies of Allah who have usurped
the blessed soil."
[44]
In August 1988
Hamas released its own covenant, (see Appendix I) a thirty-six article
document clearly stating its objectives and covering an extraordinary
range of issues. Contained in the introductory page, along with quotes
from the Koran and martyrs to the cause, is the line, "Israel will
be established and will stay established until Islam nullifies it as it
nullified what was before it." The covenant goes on to introduce
the Hamas movement and its birth saying that it "went forth to perform
its role for the sake of its Lord."
The first chapter
defines the movement, explaining its relationship to the Muslim Brotherhood
and saying that it "works towards raising the banner of Allah on
every inch of Palestine," and that it is "a link in {a long}
chain of Jihad against the Zionist occupation." It defines
itself thus:
The Islamic resistance
movement...professes a comprehensive understanding and precise conceptualization
of the Islamic precepts in all aspects of life: concept and beliefs, politics
and economics, education and social service, jurisdiction and law, exhortation
and training, communication and arts, the seen and the unseen and the
rest of life's ways. (The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement,
Article Two)
Chapter two rhetorically defines
the general objectives of the movement with an evocative introduction
which says that the movement:
...evolved in
a time where the lack of the Islamic Spirit has brought about distorted
judgement and absurd comprehension. Values have deteriorated, the plague
of the evil folk and oppression and darkness have become rampant, cowards
have become ferocious. Nations have been occupied, their people expelled
and fallen on their faces {in humiliation} everywhere on earth. The nation
of truth is absent and the nation of evil has been established; as long
as Islam does not take its rightful place in the world arena everything
will continue to change for the worse. The goal of the Islamic Resistance
movement therefore is to conquer evil, break its will and annihilate it
so that truth may prevail, so that the country may return to its rightful
place, and so that the call may be broadcast over the minarets proclaiming
the Islamic state. (The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement, Article
Nine.)
There is a strong social message
in these ideas which appeal to a broader base than religion alone - rejecting
the division of Palestine and claiming that the struggle must be for the
whole land, gives hope to those refugees outside the land, hope that they
will be able to realize their right of return to their own homes, fields
and villages. No other Palestinian political movement can embrace such
a promise.
[45]
Owing to the belief of Hamas that
all the land of Palestine is Islamic Waqf consecrated for future
Muslim generations makes Jihad or holy war inevitable. Hamas believes
itself to be the most recent link in the "chain of Jihad"
which began with the revolt of Sheikh Izz al-Din al-Qassam and his Muslim
Brotherhood comrades in the 1930s.
Article thirteen of the covenant
says:
There is no solution
to the Palestinian question except by Jihad. The initiatives, options
and international conferences are a waste of time and a kind of childs
play. The Palestinian people are nobler than to be fiddling with their
future, rights and destiny.
Article fifteen reiterates this
more strongly by stating that:
When an enemy
occupies some of the Muslim lands, Jihad becomes obligatory for
every Muslim. In the struggle against the Jewish occupation of Palestine,
the banner of Jihad must be raised.
This principle tenet of the Hamas
program addressed every able member of society as illustrated in article
twelve:
Fighting the
enemy becomes the individual obligation of every Muslim man and woman.
The woman is allowed to go fight without the permission of her husband
and the slave without the permission of his master. and in article fourteen:
The liberation
of Palestine is obligatory for every Muslim no matter where he is; Despite its apparently Islamic call
for Holy War against the Zionist entity and the establishment of what
it envisions as an Islamic state, Hamas has, especially recently, appealed
to an audience that does not necessarily share its political aims. Part
of its grass-roots appeal comes from disillusion with the secular ranks
of the PLO who are seen by many as being too weak in their resistance
to the occupiers. Hamas, meanwhile, has claimed responsibility for what
are seen by many as successful military exploits including killings of
Israeli secret agents. On the other hand, Hamas has been careful to present
a `moderate' face to those unhappy with lack of progress under PLO leadership
yet reluctant to embrace an `extremist' stance.
As Hamas has developed from being
simply an arm of the Muslim Brotherhood to a major political organization,
so it has shifted its actions to be increasingly seen as a primary source
of resistance to the occupation and therefore a legitimate challenger
to the hegemony of the PLO. Its decisions on how best to maintain this
challenge during the current peace process and vis-a-vis the possibility
of elections as part of that process are purely pragmatic.
While Hamas appeals to democratic
principles in its efforts to challenge the PLO (claiming that the PLO
leadership is not a legitimate representative of the Palestinian people
because it has not been elected, and calling for elections inside and
outside the Occupied Territories to determine the leadership), the fact
remains that it seeks not democracy in Palestine but the establishment
of sharia (Islamic law) as the only law, the interpretation of
which will be determined not by an elected government but by the Supreme
'Ulama:
The Islamic Resistance
Movement: Islam is its system. From Islam it reaches for its ideology,
fundamental precepts and world view of life, the universe and humanity;
and it judges all its actions according to Islam and is inspired by Islam
to correct its errors. (The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement,
Article One).
The claim of each fundamentalist
movement, of whatever religion, is that it provides all the answers to
all facets of life. Therefore, of course, everything else is wrong and,
because the apparently correct path is founded on religious belief, somehow
sinful, blasphemous and corrupt. Hamas seeks not democracy but theocracy.
It demands not freedom but obedience, not equality but compliance, of
women to men and of the poor to the (charitable) rich. Hamas stresses
that "it is possible for all followers of different religions to
live in peace and with security" However, it claims that this can
only happen "in the shadow of Islam" in the absence of which,
"discord takes form, oppression and destruction are rampant and wars
and battles take place." (The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance
Movement, Article Six).
Fundamentalism is regressive; it
harks back to some mythical Golden Age when (religious) law was properly
observed and, therefore, society was better in every way. Hamas is no
exception and proudly proclaims that, "The historical dimension of
the Islamic Resistance Movement originates from its adoption of Islam
as a system of life. It reaches far back to the birth of the Islamic Message"
(The Covenant of the Islamic Resistance Movement, Article Five).
The belief in a prescribed magic
formula (religious or otherwise but especially in the case of fundamentalist
religion) suitable for all is not only undemocratic but inherently conservative
and in the interests of the patronizing classes. It is indeed ironic that
Hamas, which relies so much on the support of those Palestinians who feel
betrayed by the current patronizing leadership, seeks to impose another.
[43]
All leaflets issued by Hamas are available in Arabic and French
at The BirZeit University Research Centre in the West Bank town of BirZeit.
[44]
See Mishal. Shaul,"'Paper War' - Words Behind Stones: The
Intifada Leaflets." The Jerusalem Quarterly. Number Fifty-One,
Summer 1989.
[45]
Hasan. Manar, "On Fundamentalism in our Land" News
From Within. Vol. VIII - No. 10/11 - Oct.Nov. 1992. pp 24
|