|
The first nine months of
1995 in Palestine saw conditions similar to those of the previous year:
frustrating and seemingly fruitless negotiations with Israel, further land
confiscations and human rights abuses and continuing armed operations by
the Islamic opposition. Important events, however, took place over the
final three months of the year. Towards the end of September, the
Palestinian Authority (PA) and Israel signed the Taba Agreement, the
second stage of the process begun with the Oslo and Cairo Agreements. The
most dramatic events of the year were two assassinations: the first of
Islamic Jihad leader Fathi Shiqaqi by Israeli agents in Malta on 26
October, the second that of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin by a
Jewish extremist on 4 November.
Continuing Negotiations with Israel
Throughout early 1995,
several meetings between Chairman Yasir Arafat, PM Yitzhak Rabin and
Deputy PM Shimon Peres and failed to achieve any result towards extending
self rule in the West Bank. In March, Arafat and Peres agreed on a
deadline of 1 July for reaching an agreement. When this passed, 25 July
became the new target. It was the cause of no little surprise when the
400-page Taba Agreement was finally reached, with the official signing
ceremony taking place in Washington on 28 September.
The Taba Agreement
The Taba Agreement divides
the West Bank, excluding East Jerusalem, into three categories: area A:
six major towns (excluding Hebron), from which the IDF redeployed by the
end of the year, handing administrative control to the PA with joint
PA-IDF patrols, and Israeli security duties including right of ‘hot
pursuit’; area B: a patchwork of Palestinian villages, in which the PA
has civil authority, while the IDF retains overall "security
responsibility"; and area C: Jewish settlements and areas defined by
the Israelis as militarily sensitive, where Israel remains in full
occupation. In Hebron, the IDF retains full control of the Ibrahimi
Mosque, and the central district of the city in which settlers occupy five
buildings. A partial IDF redeployment from Hebron was scheduled for March
1996 but subsequently delayed until after the Israeli election in May
1996. In sum, the PA gained various degrees of limited administrative
control over 27% of the West Bank, with the Israelis retaining effective
control over the entire area.
The complexity and
difficulties in the implementation of the agreement were made apparent in
October, when the Israelis presented redeployment maps differing from
those agreed on at Taba, while Israeli President Weizmann refused to free
four women prisoners whose unconditional release had been agreed.
Nonetheless, 600 political and 200 civil prisoners were released on 10
October, and on the same day, the redeployment process began, with the PA
establishing its presence in the village of Salfit near Jenin.
Caretaker Prime Minister
Shimon Peres seemed to take advantage of the disarray in the Israeli right
following the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin to accelerate the process.
The IDF redeployed from Jenin on 13 November, and the Palestinian police
entered the city.
The same process was
repeated in five further towns in the West Bank: Tulkarm (10 December),
Nablus (11 December), Qalqilya (16 December), Bethlehem (21 December) and
Ramallah (27 December).
Preparations for Elections and Internal
Political Developments
Throughout the year various
new political factions were formed, such as the Palestine National
Grouping headed by Bassam Shaka’a and the National Democratic Coalition
led by Haider Abd al-Shafi. Dialogue between the PA and the Hamas movement
continued throughout the year. Following the Taba Agreement, PA and Hamas
officials met in Cairo, with Israel facilitating the travel of Hamas
leaders from the Palestinian Territories. The talks covered the elections;
participation by Hamas in the PA; military attacks on Israel and detainees
in Israeli prisons.
The year ended with the
prospect of Palestinians in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and
Gaza voting in a political election for the first time, for an 88-member
Legislative Council and President of the Authority. Executive powers will
be exercised by a cabinet, 80% of whom will be members of the council, and
20% appointed by the president.
Voter registration began on
12 November. By the end of the month, 350 000 Gaza Strip residents had
received voting cards. Registration in East Jerusalem was initially
sporadic due to fears that registration might compromise residency rights
in the city. The electoral law proposed by the PA was the cause of
controversy, dividing the West Bank and Gaza in 16 districts with varying
numbers of seats in each district. Candidates were to be elected by simple
majority, leading to fears that the system would not give a fair chance
for small parties to gain seat, but favour the main faction, Fatah, to
gain a stronger position. Nevertheless, the law was ratified by the PA in
late November. By the time nominations closed, 700 candidates had
registered. Despite their decision to boycott the election, the religious
and secular opposition urged their supporters to exercise their right to
register as voters.
The Palestinian Authority
1995 began with a symbolic
demonstration of state-building, as Chairman Arafat mailed the first
letter with a Palestinian stamp. Equally symbolically, however, the letter
had to be put inside a second envelope with an Israeli stamp on it in
order to be delivered. On 31 January, the PNA-appointed Mufti of Jerusalem
announced the start of Ramadan, the first time the fast had begun without
the go-ahead from Cairo or Amman. The first Palestinian passports were
issued in March, and in April, the first group of Palestinian passport
holders set out on the pilgrimage to Mecca. In May, plans for an airport
in Rafah were announced, and in June, Palestinian Television began
broadcasting, initially for two hours daily.
In February, Palestine and
South Africa established full diplomatic ties at ambassadorial level.
Foreign visitors included the Troika of European Union Foreign Ministers
in February, which visited Chairman Arafat in Gaza and met with a
Palestinian delegation headed by Faisal Husseini at Orient House in East
Jerusalem, British PM John Major, US Vice President Al Gore in March and
German Chancellor Helmut Kohl in June.
Human Rights
The conduct of the Israeli
government and security forces continued to call their commitment to peace
into question during 1995. By the end of the year, it was estimated that
91 Palestinians, including seven police officers, had been killed by
Israelis in 1995, 35 of whom were killed by the IDF, 14 by special units,
14 by settlers and 14 under interrogation. The first week of the year saw
the IDF shooting three Palestinian police officers in Gaza, an undercover
unit killing four Palestinians in Bet Liqia in the West Bank, and a
shoot-out at Erez between the IDF and Palestinian police. Also in January,
30 families were expelled from their homes in the Yatta district near
Hebron. In April, a Palestinian invalid died following interrogation at
the hands of the Israeli secret police. The form of torture which resulted
in his death, violent shaking, was endorsed by an Israeli ministerial
committee in August. Three days later a Palestinian was shot dead at a
checkpoint on the road to Jerusalem. In June, three Palestinians were
killed by the IDF entering the Gaza Strip from Egypt, three demonstrators
demanding the release of political prisoners were killed in Nablus, and an
undercover unit killed a member of Islamic Jihad. Ironically, one of
Yitzhak Rabin’s last acts as Prime Minister was to order the murder in
Malta of Islamic Jihad leader Fathi Shiqaqi.
The human rights record of
the Palestinian Authority was far from ideal. A Middle East Human ýRights
Watch report issued in February concluded that, "The PNA has not
demonstrated a commitment to installing the rule of law." In
February, Raja Sourani, Head of the Gaza Centre for Rights and Law, was
arrested for the first of several times following his criticism of the
establishment on State Security Courts in Gaza and Jericho. Several
newspapers were closed for short periods during the year, among them
al-Quds, al-Hayat al-Jadida, al-Watan and al-Istiqlal. As of September,
five Palestinians had died in PNA custody. The PNA’s policy of
attempting to prevent attacks on Israelis led to periodic mass round-ups
of Islamic and secular opposition activists, and the use of arbitrary
military or state security courts for speedy trials, often held at night.
Israeli Settlements
Continued expansion of
Israeli settlements, especially around Jerusalem, remained a serious cause
for concern in 1995, and a violation of the Oslo Agreement. In May, the
Israelis began confiscating Palestinian land throughout the West Bank in
order to build roads for the use of settlers bypassing Palestinian towns.
Prime Minister Rabin admitted that the programme, consisting of 130
kilometers of roads in total, would cost the Israeli taxpayer $250,000 per
settler family. In order to complete redeployment, thousands of dunams of
Palestinian land were expropriated, especially around Nablus, Ramallah and
Bethlehem.
The Israeli right remained
vehemently opposed to even the limited withdrawal envisaged by the
government. In February, the ‘Council for Settlement in Judea and
Samaria’ instructed all settlements in the West Bank to seize and
enclose areas surrounding settlements designated as ‘state land’. A
further land grabbing campaign began in June, aimed at undermining the
Taba negotiations. This intensified the following month with settlers
closing off roads and attacking Palestinians and their property; the IDF
did not intervene except to suppress Palestinian counter-demonstrators. In
July, The Israeli authorities, however, did act to disperse 1,500 settlers
who had camped at al-Khader near Bethlehem in protest against the prospect
of redeployment. In the same month, several settlement rabbis issued a
religious judgement that Israeli soldiers were obliged to disobey orders
regarding the evacuation of settlements.
Settler violence resulted
in the deaths of 14 Palestinians over the year. Incidents included an
attack on the Qutuba girls’ school in Hebron in September, following
which 25 pupils and 20 toddlers from a nearby kindergarten were
hospitalised. The IDF intervened on the side of the settlers, attacking
parents with teargas and rubber bullets. The next month, Israel TV
reported that settlers and rightists were planning to form a militia to
resist any attempts to evacuate settlements. The strains in Israeli
society culminated in the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin by a right wing
extremist on 4 November.
Jerusalem
Despite negotiations on the
future of Jerusalem being due to begin in May 1996, Israeli politicians
made repeated statements that the issue was closed. Palestinian daily life
in the city remained hampered by Israeli restrictions. East Jerusalem
remained under the closure imposed since March 1993, with Palestinians
from the rest of the West Bank and Gaza still prevented from entering the
city without permits. Settlement activity around the city continued apace.
A crisis erupted in early May with the announcement of the biggest land
confiscation proposal in Jerusalem since 1980, covering 130 acres of
Palestinian land in the Beit Hanina and Beit Safafa areas. This, it was
announced, was the first stage of a plan by the West Jerusalem
Municipality to seize a further 1,000 acres of Palestinian land in the
city. The Palestinian Authority could do no more than condemn the
expropriation, and the United States vetoed a muted Security Council
Resolution condemning the measure. In the event it was a combination of
the Arab parties in the Knesset and the political ineptitude on the part
of Israeli PM Rabin which led to the freezing of the move. Rabin declared
a motion condemning the expropriation a matter of confidence, leading to
the Likud threatening to vote for the motion in order to bring down the
government. In the face of this, the government withdrew the proposal.
The Israeli West Jerusalem
Municipality began a campaign to destroy ‘unlicensed’ Palestinian
homes. In May alone, 27 demolition orders were signed, compared to 19 for
the whole of 1994. Palestinian national institutions in the city were
subject to harassment, three being briefly closed in July. Orient House
was subject to settler demonstrations and harassment throughout the
summer, with children attending the nearby Dar al-Tifl school also
suffering at the hands of settlers and police. In November, Rabin
announced that he would not meet any foreign visitor of the rank of
minister or above who had visited Orient House. In December, new residency
regulations for Palestinians became apparent, with children whose mothers,
but not fathers, were registered as Jerusalem residents, denied residency
rights in the city.
Opposition
The conduct of the Israeli
government and settlers did much to provoke continued armed operations by
elements of the Palestinian opposition. Bus bombings took place in
January, July and August, leading to tension between the PA and the
religious opposition, and mass detentions of opposition activists. In
April, an explosion killed five Palestinians, among them a Hamas member,
in Gaza’s Sheikh Radwan neighborhood. Hamas accused the PA of
collaboration with the Israelis, with the PA accusing Hamas of
recklessness in storing explosives in a residential area. In retaliation,
two suicide bombers attacked settlers and IDF personnel in the Gaza Strip.
Much of the dialogue between the PA and Hamas which took place throughout
the year was aimed ending such tension, and seemed to succeed, with no
major armed operations taking place in 1995 after August. |